I still don't know how Natal is going to be realized. How do they simulate all of the buttons? What if I don't want to get off the couch?! One of the issues I have with motion controllers, in general, is that they are no longer casual controllers that I can just pick up and play while on the couch.
I don't like using the Wii-mote when in a chair with an arm... I have the same issue playing High Velocity Bowling, I have to stand up or I hit the arm of the chair when rolling. I may not be the target market for these controllers, but maybe you aren't either, laggmaster?
Have you used the Move? ...and then how do you know it is just "another wii wand"?! From all the info provided to date, this is intended to take it to the next level. One of the biggest issues with the Wii is the lack of accuracy. This is intended to fix that weakness. Couple that with games that grown-ups actually like to play, and it sounds like a winner.