Australian PS3 Gamer Loses OtherOS Lawsuit to Sony


189w ago - While everyone awaits a verdict on the injunction in the recent PS JailBreak lawsuit hearing, another Australian PS3 gamer has lost his OtherOS lawsuit to Sony recently.

According to GamePron.com (linked above) Michael Trebilcock had asked for AU $800 in compensation (the cost to rent a laptop for each day he was unable to use Linux on his PS3, plus fees), with a claim that the updated console could no longer be used as a computer.

To quote: "Unfortunately for Trebilcock, the Magistrates court heard that the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission cleared Sony of any wrongdoing regarding the upgrade, and the claim was dismissed.

Mr. Trebilcock was not made to pay Sony's legal costs."



Stay tuned for more PS3 Hacks and PS3 CFW news, follow us on Twitter and be sure to drop by the PS3 Hacks and PS3 Custom Firmware Forums for the latest PlayStation 3 scene updates and homebrew releases!

Comments 12 Comments - Go to Forum Thread »

Quick Reply Quick Reply

nofunatall's Avatar
#12 - nofunatall - 188w ago
agreed. i think you are spot on gemini.

clouduzz's Avatar
#11 - clouduzz - 189w ago
B) Network access, online play, to-be-released game titles, BluRay compatibility

If Sony didn't purposefully prevent you from playing to-be-released game titles (by checking the OS version), then they may have more room to legally withhold online play and 'feature updates'.

BUT forcing users to update (by requiring the OS update, in order to continue using the PS3 system for to-be-released game titles) is the crux of the issue.

Couldn't have said it better myself, that's why I'm glad the system is finally exploited now they will see how it feels to get screwed over! Not to mention when it was rumored that they were taking it away they flat out denied it and then did it anyway. So screw Sony

gemini420's Avatar
#10 - gemini420 - 189w ago
As stated before when the lawsuit was filed, $ony can do what it wants. we agree to the user terms and agreements .. and we also have a choice u either upgrade the fw and loose OtherOS or keep OtherOS by not upgrading.

when i bought both of my ps3 i bought it to be used as a gaming system if i want linux i can use a real pc. and just to answer the comment some will post " i paid $499.99 and now we loose OtherOs" its like anything else, when a device first comes out we pay extra $$ for this commodity soon the price drops like now ps3 cost $299.99, i say the extra $200.00 i paid "then" has well been worth it for all the gaming i've done, and i'm sure most will agree.
Just because Sony wrote a EULA that covers their own butt (in every conceivable situation they could think of), does not mean that it will be legally upheld in court.

You need to consider when you agreed to that EULA. Was it before you purchased (and opened PS3, and used the PS3)? No, it was afterward.

Did you purchase the PS3 system based on Sony's advertised features? Yes.

Does a manufacturer have the right (regardless of the manufacturers claims) to retroactively alter the product to remove advertised features? Courts will decide this, not the manufacturer ...

Product manufacturers would love to take your money and then retroactively do what is in their own best interest. This is why there are consumer rights, and there are courts to uphold those rights.

Normally, product manufacturers do not go down this path. But, Sony chose to do so. EULAs like this are rarely challenged in court.

No questions asked, this is new ground. And could set a very scary precedent *if* Sony is allowed to disable advertised features as they choose. It will redefine the concept of 'purchased property'.

No matter how you look at it, Sony is removing advertised features ...

Choose to loose either ...

A) Other OS

or

B) Network access, online play, to-be-released game titles, BluRay compatibility

If Sony didn't purposefully prevent you from playing to-be-released game titles (by checking the OS version), then they may have more room to legally withhold online play and 'feature updates'.

BUT forcing users to update (by requiring the OS update, in order to continue using the PS3 system for to-be-released game titles) is the crux of the issue.

GrandpaHomer's Avatar
#9 - GrandpaHomer - 189w ago
when i bought both of my ps3 i bought it to be used as a gaming system if i want linux i can use a real pc.

You CLEARLY have no idea at all what are you talking about

PS3 computing capacity is WAY ahead of ANY PC in it's price category (and actually even in any category above) and that's exactly WHY some people really bought for it's capability to run linux / other OS including US Army and loads of other research facilities

Tex Murphy's Avatar
#8 - Tex Murphy - 189w ago
This was just a small claim. Hopefully the class action lawsuits go the consumer's way.

It's sad that the "Australian Competition and Consumer Commission" doesn't support the consumer.













Affiliates - Contact Us - PS3 Downloads - Privacy Statement - Site Rules - Top - © 2014 PlayStation 3 News